HARBagenda052126FINAL

Historic Architectural Review Board Meeting · 2026-05-21 · agenda

[9 Masters Drive; case HP2026-0027] Item 5a: Tipton Bray, applicant for owners Liam and Dorota McDermott, seeks to demolish a residential building constructed c. 1910-1917 at 9 Masters Drive. The building is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district. This item was recommended for expedited hearing. [130 St. George Street; case HP2026-0011] Item 6a: Duncan Dailey, applicant for Old City Leasing LLC, owner of 130 St. George Street, requested a continuance for their Certificate of Appropriateness application. The original request was to replace the existing storefront with a new system and install a handicap access ramp. The hearing was continued to June 18, 2026. [78 Spanish Street; case HP2026-0028] Item 6b: 78 Spanish Leasing Agency LLC, as both applicant and owner of 78 Spanish Street, seeks to construct a new wood privacy fence and gate. [172 Cordova Street, Units 11 & 12; case HP2026-0031] Item 6c: Tri-State Builders & Remodeling LLC, applicant for owners Eric Ryden, Dawn Newton & Megan Hoag, seeks to construct a new two-story wrap-around deck on the south end of the building at 172 Cordova Street, Units 11 & 12. The deck will be visible from the Historic Preservation-One (HP-1) zoning district. [30A Bay View Drive; case HP2026-0033] Item 7a: Les Thomas, Architect, applicant for owners Francie Rubin and Margot Bradely, seeks to demolish a detached garage structure constructed c. 1953 at 30A Bay View Drive. The garage is not recorded in the Florida Master Site File but is contributing to the Fullerwood Park Residential National Register Historic District. [68 Oneida Street; case HP2026-0006] Item 7b: Sarah Ryan Architect, LLC, applicant for owners Clifton and Rachelle Miller, seeks to perform partial demolition of a residential building at 68 Oneida Street. The building was constructed c. 1871-1885, is recorded in the Florida Master Site File, and contributes to the Lincolnville National Register Historic District. The work relates to building elevation and rehabilitation, including modifications to the foundation and enclosed front porch, and removal and replacement of rear additions. This item was continued from February 19, 2026. [7 Saragossa Street; case HP2026-0022] Item 7c: A & O Builders, applicant for True Real Estate Investments, LLC, owner of 7 Saragossa Street, is seeking after-the-fact approval for partial demolition of a residential building constructed c. 1917-1924. The building is recorded in the Florida Master Site File and contributes to the Model Land Company National Register Historic District. The demolition involved wholesale replacement of windows with a different design and fenestration changes. A previous application (HP2025-0087) was denied. This item was continued from April 16, 2026. [1 Cordova Street; case HP2026-0032] Item 8a: Verizon Wireless, applicant for City of St. Augustine, owner of 1 Cordova Street, seeks to install cellular equipment on the exterior of existing parking garage stairwell towers.