HARBpacket071626

Historic Architectural Review Board Meeting · 2026-07-16 · agenda_packet

[74 King Street, Saint Augustine, 32084; 69 St. George Street, Saint Augustine, 32084; 168 Avenida Menendez (69 Marine Street), Saint Augustine, 32084; 62 Spanish Street & 59 Hypolita Street, Saint Augustine; case HP2026-0048; HP2026-0046; HP2026-0053; HP2026-0049] This document is a multi-item agenda packet for the City of St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board meeting on July 16, 2026. It contains staff reports and applications for four separate Certificate of Appropriateness cases. For each case, the document provides the address, applicant, property owner, project description, and staff recommendation. No final decisions are stated in the document; the document provides staff recommendations and notes that one applicant requested a continuance. Public comment sentiment is not stated in the document. [0 Palm Row; 54 Water Street; 62 Spanish Street; case HP2026-0040; HP2026-0047; not stated] The document is a staff report for a Historic Architectural Review Board meeting. It includes two separate applications. The first is for a new 2-story residential structure at 0 Palm Row, with a staff recommendation of approval for an Opinion of Appropriateness. The second is for partial demolition and roof replacement at 54 Water Street, with a staff recommendation of approval for a Certificate of Demolition. The document also contains a performance-based design evaluation for a building at 62 Spanish Street, but does not state a specific project action or decision for it. [54 Water Street, St. Augustine, FL 32084; 62 Fullerwood Drive, St. Augustine, FL 32084; 13 Saragossa Street, St. Augustine, FL; case HP2026-0047; HP2026-0044; HP2026-0051] The document is a staff report and application for a Certificate of Demolition (Partial) for a residential building at 54 Water Street, St. Augustine, FL. The applicant is Roofology Roofing Inc., and the property owner is the Oullette Family Trust. The case number is HP2026-0047. The project involves partial demolition of a residential building constructed c. 1872-1885, recorded in the Florida Master Site File and contributing to the Abbott Tract National Register Historic District, including replacement of existing metal roofing with metal roofing of a different design. The staff report recommends approval, contingent on the board finding that the proposed replacement maintains the historic character and integrity of the structure. The document also includes staff reports for two other projects: Application HP2026-0044 at 62 Fullerwood Drive, for partial demolition of a residential building constructed c. 1955, contributing to the Fullerwood Park Residential National Register Historic District, including replacement of existing roof material with a new material of a different design; and Application HP2026-0051 at 13 Saragossa Street, for partial demolition of a residential building constructed c. 1878-1885, contributing to the Model Land Company National Register Historic District, including modifications to existing fenestration patterns, front porch, and roof form, and demolition of a detached shed/garage structure for replacement with new. The staff report for HP2026-0044 recommends approval, and the staff report for HP2026-0051 recommends approval. The document does not state the final decisions of the board for any of the applications. No public comment or stakeholder sentiment is stated in the document. [13 Saragossa Street; 40 S. Dixie Highway; 7 Saragossa Street; case HP2026-0051; HP2026-0043; HP2026-0022] The document is part of a multi-item agenda for the City of St. Augustine Historic Architectural Review Board meeting on July 16, 2026. It includes three distinct projects: 1) 13 Saragossa Street: Application HP2026-0051 for a Certificate of Demolition (Partial) by applicant Les Thomas, Architect, and owners Carol Lopez Bradshaw and Albert & Virgina Bradshaw. The project involves partial demolition of a residential building constructed c. 1878-1885, recorded in the Florida Master Site File and contributing to the Model Land Company National Register Historic District, including modifications to fenestration, front porch, and roof form, and demolition of a detached shed/garage for replacement. Legal description: MODEL LAND CO SUB CITY W6FT OF LOT 18 & E45FT OF LOT 19 BLK K DB129/6 OR1089/1241 &1111/1602 &1606(L/A) &1172/476 & 6240/1896(L/E) & 6288/1124. Application received June 17, 2026. 2) 40 S. Dixie Highway: Application HP2026-0043 for a Certificate of Demolition (Full) by applicant Geoffrey LeShane and owner Camryn Grace LLC. The project is to demolish a commercial (originally residential) building constructed c. 1885-1894, recorded in the Florida Master Site File and not located in a district. Legal description: 1-61 LLAMBIAS ADDN LOTS 4 5 & 6 BLK C OR6320/874. Parcel number: 1247200000. Zoning District: CL-1. Staff recommends APPROVAL with possible conditions including salvage of significant materials and archival recording. Application received June 3, 2026. 3) 7 Saragossa Street: Application HP2026-0022 for an After-the-Fact Certificate of Demolition for Partial Demolition by applicant A & O Builders and owner True Real Estate Investments, LLC. The project involves partial demolition of a residential building constructed c. 1917-1924, recorded in the Florida Master Site File and contributing to the Model Land Company National Register Historic District, including wholesale replacement of windows in a different design and fenestration changes. Parcel number: 2055200000. Zoning District: RS-1. Staff recommends either CONTINUE to allow time for more detailed drawings or APPROVE if the HARB determines plans are sufficient. The application was continued from April 16, 2026, following denied application HP2025-0087. No new documentation was submitted as of July 6, 2026 deadline. An email from Frank Ringhofer dated July 8, 2026 requests a continuance to the August 20th meeting. The document does not state a final decision for any of the projects, as it is a staff report prepared for the meeting. Public comment sentiment is not stated in the document. [1 Cordova Street; case HP2026-0032] The document is a staff report and recommendation for a Certificate of Appropriateness application (HP2026-0032) for the installation of cellular equipment on the exterior of an existing parking garage stairwell towers at 1 Cordova Street. The applicant is Verizon Wireless, and the property owner is the City of St. Augustine. The application was continued from the May 21, 2026 meeting. The staff report does not make a recommendation for projects on city property. The HARB must make a determination. The document includes a notice that required documentation was not received by the July 6, 2026 deadline for the July 16, 2026 meeting. The applicant has options to request a continuance or provide walk-on new information. A mockup was scheduled for July 18 from 10 am to 12:30 pm on the east elevation of the parking garage. The document does not state a final decision. The document does not state any public comment or stakeholder sentiment. The document does not state a specific business opportunity for contractors or trades. [24 Avenida Menendez; 148 St. George Street; 290 St. George Street; 243 St. George Street; 75 King Street (Lightner); 43 ½ Cordova Street; 95 Cordova Street; 54 Cuna Street; 34 Treasury Street; 30 Bay View Drive; 47 Abbott Street] The document is a memorandum from the City of St. Augustine Planning and Building Department to the Historic Architectural Review Board, dated July 16, 2026, listing permits issued during June 2026 for projects in HP Districts and HARB approved projects. It includes repair, maintenance, new construction, and demolition permits. No specific project size, zoning change, applicant, case number, or decision is stated for any individual project. The document does not state any public comment or stakeholder sentiment.