April 29th, 2026, Historic Preservation Board Meeting Agenda Packet
April 29, 2026 Historic Preservation Board · 2026-04-29 · agenda_packet
[110 N Clayton Street; case Not stated (referred to as Tab 1 - Certificate of Appropriateness)] The Historic Preservation Board is considering a Certificate of Appropriateness for a new garage addition at 110 N Clayton Street. The project involves removing an existing deck and shed and constructing a concrete block garage with a patio on top. The applicant, Carolyn K Parlato, seeks to replace the existing garage door with a matching one. Staff recommends approval, finding the proposal consistent with historic design standards regarding compatibility, location, and subordination to the primary structure. The property is zoned R-1 with a Medium Density land use. The construction year of the existing structure is 1952, and its style is Masonry Vernacular. [115 W 3rd Avenue] The Historic Preservation Board is reviewing a Certificate of Appropriateness for a renovation project at 115 W 3rd Avenue. The agenda lists this item for discussion, including ex parte communication, staff and applicant presentations, public comment, and board discussion. No decision or specific details of the renovation are provided in the agenda. [351 W 10th Street] The Historic Preservation Board is reviewing a Certificate of Appropriateness for a window renovation at 351 W 10th Street. The agenda lists this item for discussion, including ex parte communication, staff and applicant presentations, public comment, and board discussion. No decision or specific details of the renovation are provided in the agenda. [606 N McDonald Street] The Historic Preservation Board is reviewing a Certificate of Appropriateness for an addition at 606 N McDonald Street. The agenda lists this item for discussion, including ex parte communication, staff and applicant presentations, public comment, and board discussion. No decision or specific details of the addition are provided in the agenda. [610 N. Tremain Street] The Historic Preservation Board approved the application for a reroof at 610 N. Tremain Street. Staff recommended approval, and the board unanimously approved the application as presented. Discussions included whether the property is a duplex and mimicking gridlines. [1148 N. Grandview Street] The Historic Preservation Board approved the application for a reroof at 1148 N. Grandview Street. Staff recommended approval, and the board unanimously approved the application. Staff clarified that the application was for the entire roof. [811 N. Grandview Street] The Historic Preservation Board approved the application for window/door renovation at 811 N. Grandview Street, with the condition that grid lines are replicated on new windows. Staff recommended approval with this condition. Discussions involved ordinance provisions on replacement materials and the nature of a patio door. [729 E. 8th Avenue] The Historic Preservation Board tabled the application for window replacement at 729 E. 8th Avenue until the next meeting. Staff recommended approval with conditions for replicating gridlines. Discussions involved vinyl windows, architectural curves preventing replication of front windows, and the owner's stated reasons for replacement (leaking windows, rotting frames). The owner, Diane Hartwell, presented photos. The board decided to table the item to allow for a representative/contractor to be available for further questions.
Agenda items
- 1. Accept Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application, as presented;
- 1. Accept Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application, as presented;
- 1. Accept Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application, as presented;
- Legal Services
- Engineering & Architecture
- 1. Basic requirements.
- 1. Construct a 784 SF , concrete block addition with architectural shingles , windows with
- General Contractor
- Concrete & Masonry
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 1. Construct a 784 SF , concrete block addition with architectural shingles , windows with
- General Contractor
- Concrete & Masonry
- Roofing
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Painting & Flooring
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 1. Height. The height of proposed buildings or modifications will be visually compatible in
- General Contractor
- Engineering & Architecture
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Signage & Printing
- 1. Historic site. No building, structure, appurtenance, improvement
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Government Authority
- 1. Located within the city, there are archaeological sites, buildings, structures, 4
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- Construction (Other)
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Appraisal & Inspection
- 1. Porch Additions: Porches should not be added to a primary façade if the building did not
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Construction (Other)
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 1. The new metal roof shall be standing seam with concealed fastener in an earthy or muted
- Roofing
- 1. The request is consistent with the Mount Dora Historic Design Standards which state that
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 1. The request is consistent with the Mount Dora Historic Design Standards which state that
- 1. The subject residence was constructed in 1954 and a two-story addition was added in 2007;
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 10. Scale of building. The size of a building, the building mass in relation to open spaces,
- 10. Traditional Materials: The continued use of traditional materials such as wood, stone,
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Construction (Other)
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Design & Creative
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 11. Directional expression of front elevation. A building will be visually compatible with the
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- 11. Roof Materials: Select roof materials that are similar in type, pattern, form, texture, and
- 12. Metal Roofs: New metal roofing is acceptable provided that the new metal roof is metal
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- 13. Entrance Porches: Entrance porches and porticos of various configurations are present
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Construction (Other)
- Painting & Flooring
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 14. Window Expression and Placement : Windows attract the eye, so it is important to
- 15. Porches: The incorporation of porches in new construction is encouraged. Design should
- 16. Primary Entrances: Preserve and retain the primary entrances of buildings in their historic
- 17. Secondary Entrances : Preserve and retain secondary entrances on the side or rear of
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- Appraisal & Inspection
- 18. Closing Historic Entrances : Do not remove, close, or fill in historic entrances, as this
- 19. New Entrances: New entrances should be located on the side or rear façades in locations
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- General Contractor
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- 2. Add a 196 SF front porch with a metal roof and 6’X6’ pressure treated posts over the
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 2. Add a 196 SF front porch with a metal roof and 6’X6’ pressure treated posts over the
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 2. Building Orientation: New construction should have a similar orientation and relationship
- 2. Front facade proportion. The front facade of each building or structure will be visually
- Engineering & Architecture
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Real Estate Development
- 2. Historic preservation review area. A certificate of appropriateness
- 2. Partially reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application with conditions to
- 2. Partially reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application with conditions to
- 2. Partially reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application with conditions to
- 2. The 2008 Site Survey stated that the resource has lost much of its historic integrity and
- 2. The request is consistent with the Mount Dora Historic Design Standards which
- 2. The request is consistent with the Mount Dora Historic Design Standards which state
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Electrical
- Painting & Flooring
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 2. The windows on western façade include the sh utters and grid lines depicted in the
- 2. Through this and other dedicated efforts of local public and private groups and 11
- 20. Later Windows: Windows that have been added through subsequent historic periods can
- 21. Window Openings: Avoid enlarging, reducing, or filling in historic window openings.
- 22. Shutter Installation : The installation of historically appropriate shutters on historic
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- 23. Shutter Size and Configuration: New shutters should match the height and width of the
- 24. Shutter Materials and Design: Shutters may be wood or a composite material and should
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Construction (Other)
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- 25. Inappropriate Shutter Locations: Shutters should not be installed on windows that would
- 26. New Windows : New windows should not be introduced to any primary façade. New
- 27. New Window Design : The type, size, placement, and detailing of new windows on
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- 3. Close in and reconfigure the window openings on the western façade in the entrance area;
- 3. Close in and reconfigure the window openings on the western façade in the entrance area;
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- 3. Entrance Orientation : Primary entrances of new buildings should be on the primary
- 3. Proportion of openings (windows and doors). The openings of any building within a
- Engineering & Architecture
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Painting & Flooring
- Real Estate Development
- 3. Reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Deny the application based on inconsistencies between
- Legal Services
- Engineering & Architecture
- General Contractor
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- 3. Reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Deny the application based on inconsistencies between
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- 3. Reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Deny the application based on inconsistencies between
- Legal Services
- Engineering & Architecture
- 3. The proposed changes are compatible with the existing residence, utilizes the same façade
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Engineering & Architecture
- 3. The proposed work is compatible with the architectural style of the building; and
- 3. The request is promotes visual compatibility with the exterior architectural of adjacent,
- Construction (Other)
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- 4. Close in and relocate one of the front entrances to the proposed addition;
- 4. Close in and relocate one of the front entrances to the proposed addition;
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 4. Rhythm of solids to voids —Front facades. The relationship of solids to voids in the front
- Engineering & Architecture
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Drywall & Insulation
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Roofing
- Concrete & Masonry
- Lighting & Low-Voltage Systems
- Construction (Other)
- 4. Setbacks: Where there are established and consistent setbacks, setbacks of new
- 4. The request is promotes visual compatibility with the exterior architectural of adjacent,
- Construction (Other)
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- Real Estate Development
- 4. The request promotes visual compatibility with the exterior architectural of adjacent,
- 5. Enclose and reconfigure window and door openings on eastern façade (rear of the house);
- 5. Enclose and reconfigure window and door openings on eastern façade (rear of the house);
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- General Contractor
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 5. Rhythm of buildings on streets. The relationship of building(s) to open space between it or
- Engineering & Architecture
- Business Consulting
- Design & Creative
- 5. Size Location of Additions : Additions should be located on the side or rear elevation as
- 6. Add a window on the second story of the northern façade (side of house); and
- 6. Add a window on the second story of the northern façade (side of house); and
- 6. Complementary Expression : New construction should take inspiration from and be
- 6. Rhythm of entrance and/or porch projections. The relationship of entrances and porch
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 7. Compatible New Design: New construction and additions can utilize modern technologies
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 7. Relationship to materials and texture. The relationship of materials and texture of the
- 7. Stucco the block home and proposed addition.
- 7. Stucco the block home and proposed addition.
- Concrete & Masonry
- General Contractor
- Painting & Flooring
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- 8. Proportion of Additions: Additions should be subordinate to, and not overwhelm, the
- 8. Roof shapes. The roof shape of a building or structure will be visually compatible with the
- 9. Solids-to-Voids Proportions: The rhythm and pattern of fenestration (the arrangement
- 9. Walls of continuity. Appearances of a building or structure such as walls, wrought -iron
- A. 610 N. Tremain Street - Reroof
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- B. 1148 N. Grandview Street - Reroof
- Roofing
- C. 811 N. Grandview Street – Window/Door Renovation
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- Cc: Scott, Whitney
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- D. 729 E. 8th Avenue – Window Replacement
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Construction (Other)
- E: willist@mountdora.gov (Email)
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- IX. Announcement of next scheduled meeting date; May 27, 2026 @ 3:00 p.m.
- IX. Announcement of next scheduled meeting date; May 27, 2026 @ 3:00 p.m.
- N. Baker St.
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Drywall & Insulation
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- N. Baker St.
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Electrical
- Plumbing
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Drywall & Insulation
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- T: (352) 735-7112 Ext. 1709 (Office)
- V. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
- V. Certificate of Appropriateness
- V. Certificate of Appropriateness
- VII. OTHER BUSINESS
- VIII. ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT SCHEDULED MEETING DATE: April 29, 2026 (3:00pm)
- a. 110 N Clayton Street - New Garage
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- a. 110 N Clayton Street - New Garage
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Appraisal & Inspection
- Engineering & Architecture
- a. Certificate of appropriateness required.
- a. Fifty years old or older; or
- a. General Layout: Retain historic property line patterns, street relationships, setbacks,
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- a. Historic Ordinance Update
- a. Historic Ordinance Update
- a. Retain Historic Frames: When possible, replace only the sash, leaving the historic frame
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- b. 115 W 3rd Avenue - Renovation
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- b. 115 W 3rd Avenue - Renovation
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Cleaning & Janitorial
- b. Demolition by Neglect
- b. Demolition by Neglect
- b. New additions or when a structure is erected construction.
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- b. Size Location of Additions: Additions should be located on the side or rear elevation as
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- b. Window Size: New windows should be fabricated to match the full size of the historic
- c. 351 W 10th Street - Window Renovation
- Construction (Other)
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- Appraisal & Inspection
- c. 729 E. 8th Ave- Window Replacement (Tabled)
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- c. Compatible New Design: New construction and additions can utilize modern technologies
- c. Vinyl as Special Exceptions: For new construction, accessory buildings, rear additions to
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- General Contractor
- Engineering & Architecture
- d. 351 W 10th Street - Window Renovation
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- Business Consulting
- Appraisal & Inspection
- d. 606 N McDonald Street Addition
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Electrical
- Plumbing
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- d. Dormer Windows: Windows should complement the character of the historic windows,
- d. Proportion of Additions: Additions should be subordinate to, and not overwhelm, the
- e. 606 N McDonald Street Addition
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- e. Compatibility: Materials should be of a complementary type, size, texture, color and level
- e. Preservation: Preserve, repair, and maintain historic porches associated with buildings in
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- f. Enclosing Original Porches: Historic porches should not be enclosed with walls and/or
- f. Inappropriate Materials: The use of vinyl and aluminum siding, unpainted wood,
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Construction (Other)
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Appraisal & Inspection
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- Cleaning & Janitorial
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Signage & Printing
- g. Limited Enclosures: On secondary or rear elevations, porch enclosures may be permitted
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- g. Porches: The incorporation of porches in new construction is encouraged. Design should
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- iv. Applicant Presentation
- v. Discussion
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- v. Discussion
- Roofing
- v. Discussion
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- General Contractor
- v. Discussion
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
Follow this across meetings
Applicants and firms
See the actual businesses behind these numbers
Get the real filings, with addresses and officers, backed by a 14-day money-back guarantee.
Create your account