May 27, 2026, Historic Preservation Board Meeting_Agenda
May 27, 2026 Historic Preservation Board · 2026-05-27 · minutes
[751 E Fifth Avenue] Project at 751 E Fifth Avenue for Exterior Improvements was approved. The project involved Ex Parte Communication Disclosure, Swearing in of staff/applicants, Staff presentation, Applicant Presentation, Public Comment, and Board Discussion. Mr. Winkler provided a brief summary of the proposed application and stated that the staff recommends approval of the application as presented. The board voted to approve the application as presented unanimously with a 4-0 vote. [822 Alexander Street] Project at 822 Alexander Street for Re-roof was deferred. The project involved Ex Parte Communication Disclosure, Swearing in of staff/applicants, Staff presentation, Applicant Presentation, Public Comment, and Board Discussion. Mr. Winkler provided a brief summary of the proposed application and stated that the staff recommends disapproving the application as presented. Mr. Canzater advised existing roof is not a standing seam roof. Discussion on a standing seam roof would be a downgrade from what the property owner chose. The slate is approximately 30 percent upgrade. Mr. Canzater confirmed the product is a synthetic "plastic." Discussion on synthetic products being recyclable. Mr. Canzater provided additional samples of metal roofing in various shapes. Mr. Canzater advised the insurance company requiring the roof to be replaced in order to be covered. Mr. Canzater and Mr. Marlow convened to discuss options. Re-convened. Mr. Marlow advised he needs more time to research metal roofing. Mr. Marlow requesting a continuance to the June 24, 2026, meeting. Motion by Daniel Wick, seconded by Joseph Newton; the board voted to TABLE the application until the June 24, 2026, meeting, unanimously with a 4-0 vote.
Agenda items
- 1. Accept Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application, as presented;
- 1. Complementary Expression: New construction should take inspiration from and be
- 1. Construct a covered porch with open courtyard along the western façade, fronting Clayton
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- 1. Constructing a covered porch with open courtyard along the western façade, fronting
- General Contractor
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 1. Identifying, retaining, and preserving masonry features that are important in defining the
- Concrete & Masonry
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- Business Consulting
- Cleaning & Janitorial
- Repair & Dry Cleaning
- 1. New Additions: Synthetic materials such as fiber cement board or composites may be used
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Construction (Other)
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 1. New Wood Fencing : New wood fencing should be similar to existing historic fence
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- 1. Porch Additions: Porches should not be added to a primary façade if the building did not
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Roofing
- Construction (Other)
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- 1. Reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application, as presented, after determining
- Roofing
- General Contractor
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 1. Removing or radically changing masonry features which are important in defining the
- 1. Secondary Entrances: Preserve and retain secondary entrances on the side or rear of
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Engineering & Architecture
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Appraisal & Inspection
- 1. The Mount Dora Historic Design Standards state, ‘replace historic roofing materials such
- 1. The new metal roof shall be standing seam with a concealed fastener in an earthy or muted color;
- 1. The request is consistent with the Mount Dora Historic Design Standards which
- 2. Applying compatible paint coating systems following proper surface preparation.
- 2. Applying paint or other coatings such as stucco to masonry that has been historically
- Painting & Flooring
- Concrete & Masonry
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 2. Appropriate Materials: Plastic or vinyl fencing and chain link fencing are not appropriate
- 2. Compatible New Design: New construction and additions can utilize modern technologies
- General Contractor
- Engineering & Architecture
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Real Estate Development
- Design & Creative
- 2. Construct an entry pagoda;
- 2. Constructing an entry pagoda; and
- 2. Partially reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application with conditions to
- 2. Partially reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Approve the application with conditions to
- 2. Porch Trim, Balusters, and Related Balcony Features: Open-air porches and balconies
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 2. The Mount Dora Historic Design Standards state ‘When in-kind replacement of the historic
- 2. The request is consistent with the Mount Dora Historic Design Standards which state that
- 2. The windows on the western façade include the shutters and grid lines depicted in the application.
- Painting & Flooring
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 3. Accept Staff’s Findings of Fact and Deny the application based on inconsistencies between
- General Contractor
- Engineering & Architecture
- Legal Services
- Appraisal & Inspection
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 3. Architectural Detailing: New designs should incorporate architectural detailing visually
- 3. Construct wood slat fencing around the proposed courtyard; and
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- 3. Constructing wood slat fencing around the proposed courtyard.
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 3. Reject Staff’s Findings of Fact and Deny the application based on inconsistencies between
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- 3. Removing paint from historically painted masonry.
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Concrete & Masonry
- Engineering & Architecture
- Cleaning & Janitorial
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 3. The Mount Dora Historic Design Standards state, ‘Original metal shingle roofs are scarce
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Construction (Other)
- 3. The request promotes visual compatibility with the exterior architectural of adjacent,
- 4. Dramatic Contrast: While new buildings should clearly be distinguished from historic
- 4. Place composite wood trellises on the southern façade.
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Painting & Flooring
- Construction (Other)
- Building & Industrial Supply
- 4. Radically changing the type of paint or coating or its color.
- 4. Slate Shingles are not compatible with the architectural style of the building; and
- Roofing
- 5. Applying waterproof, water-repellent, or non-historic coatings such as stucco to masonry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Engineering & Architecture
- 5. Proportion of Additions : Additions should be subordinate to, and not overwhelm, the
- 5. The request does not promote visual compatibility with the exterior architectural of
- 6. Compatibility: Materials should be of a complementary type, size, texture, color and level
- 7. Traditional Materials: The continued use of traditional materials such as wood, stone,
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Design & Creative
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- 8. Decks and Patios : Outdoor decks and patios should be located to the side and rear of
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Concrete & Masonry
- Construction (Other)
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- A. 110 N Clayton Street – New Garage
- General Contractor
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Building & Industrial Supply
- B. 115 W 3rd Avenue - Renovation
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Roofing
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- C. 351 W 10th Street - Renovation
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- D. 606 N McDonald Street - Addition
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Concrete & Masonry
- Drywall & Insulation
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Roofing
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- E. 729 E 8th Avenue – Window Replacement (Tabled)
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Construction (Other)
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- Building & Industrial Supply
- N. Baker St.
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Electrical
- Plumbing
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Title & Settlement Services
- Legal Services
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- N. Baker St.
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Concrete & Masonry
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Electrical
- Plumbing
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Roofing
- Painting & Flooring
- Drywall & Insulation
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Appraisal & Inspection
- V. CERTIFICATE OF APPROPRIATENESS
- V. Certificate of Appropriateness
- V. Certificate of Appropriateness
- VII. ANNOUNCEMENT OF NEXT SCHEDULED MEETING DATE:
- VII. Announcement of next scheduled meeting date; June 24, 2026 @ 3:00 p.m.
- VII. Announcement of next scheduled meeting date; June 24, 2026 @ 3:00 p.m.
- a. 751 E Fifth Avenue – Exterior Improvements
- Construction (Other)
- Painting & Flooring
- Engineering & Architecture
- a. 751 E Fifth Avenue – Exterior Improvements
- General Contractor
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- a. Historic Ordinance
- Legal Services
- Engineering & Architecture
- a. Historic Roofing: Whenever possible, replace historic roofing materials such as terra cotta
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- b. 822 Alexander Street – Re-Roof
- Roofing
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Painting & Flooring
- b. 822 Alexander Street – Re-Roof
- Roofing
- General Contractor
- b. Demolition by Neglect
- b. Substitute Materials: When in-kind replacement of the historic material is not feasible,
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Business Consulting
- c. Metal Replacement: Replacement metal roofing should match the original metal roof in
- d. Metal Shingle Replacement: Original metal shingle roofs are scarce and hold significant
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Engineering & Architecture
- Appraisal & Inspection
- e. Metal Replacement for Asphalt Shingle: Replacement of conventional shingle roofs with
- Roofing
- Building & Industrial Supply
- General Contractor
- Engineering & Architecture
- f. Asphalt Shingles: Asphalt shingles are a popular contemporary roofing material. In
- g. Substrate Inspection: During roof replacement, roofing substrates should be inspected
- h. Protection of Features: During roof replacement, protect adjacent historic features such
- Roofing
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- General Contractor
- Building & Industrial Supply
- iv. Applicant Presentation
- iv. Applicant Presentation
- iv. Applicant Presentation
- iv. Applicant Presentation
- iv. Applicant Presentation
- vi. Board Discussion
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Painting & Flooring
- Plumbing
- Electrical
- HVAC & Climate Control
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Roofing
- Drywall & Insulation
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Real Estate Development
- Engineering & Architecture
- Landscaping & Lawn Service
- Government Authority
- vi. Board Discussion
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Carpentry & Cabinetry
- Restoration & Waterproofing
- Painting & Flooring
- vi. Board Discussion
- vi. Board Discussion
- Windows, Doors & Glass
- Engineering & Architecture
- Real Estate Development
- Building & Industrial Supply
- Government Authority
- vi. Board Discussion
- Concrete & Masonry
- General Contractor
- Site Prep, Grading & Hardscape
- Building & Industrial Supply
Follow this across meetings
Applicants and firms
See the actual businesses behind these numbers
Get the real filings, with addresses and officers, backed by a 14-day money-back guarantee.
Create your account